That’s kind of what I’m worried about—once you pull a window, who knows what you’ll find. I’ve only watched a bunch of YouTube vids so far, but nobody ever shows the “oh wow, my framing’s rotted” part. I guess the real cost is tools, surprise repairs, and a lot of time if you’re new. Still, I’m tempted just for the learning experience...plus, I’d love an excuse to buy more tools.
That’s exactly what happened to me—pulled out an old window in our 70s ranch and, sure enough, the sill was half gone from rot. Ended up running to the store for pressure-treated lumber and a few more tools than I’d planned. Still, even with surprise costs, it was cheaper than hiring out. Have you checked if your windows are original, or were they replaced before? That can make a big difference in what you might find behind them.
Ended up running to the store for pressure-treated lumber and a few more tools than I’d planned. Still, even with surprise costs, it was cheaper than hiring out.
Yeah, that’s the story of every “simple” DIY job at my place. I swear, I go in thinking it’ll be a quick swap, then I’m crawling under the house looking for my sanity (and a missing screwdriver). But, I gotta agree—it’s still way less painful on the wallet than hiring pros. My place had a mix of original and 90s replacements, and the originals were a total can of worms. If you’re not scared of a little rot and some surprise expenses, doing it yourself is usually worth it. Just budget for at least two extra trips to the hardware store... minimum.
Man, I feel this so much. Every time I take on a “quick project,” it somehow turns into a full-blown episode of Tool Time, complete with missing screws and questionable life choices. But yeah, even with all the extra trips and random expenses, I end up spending way less than the quotes I get from contractors. Plus, there’s some satisfaction in knowing the window won’t fall out next time there’s a stiff breeze... probably.
I end up spending way less than the quotes I get from contractors.
That’s not always the case. Most folks forget to factor in things like proper flashing, disposal fees, or if you need to buy new tools. Seen a lot of DIY jobs come my way for fixes that cost more in the end. Sometimes paying upfront saves headaches (and drafts) later.
- Had the same thought, but after doing two windows myself, I get where you’re coming from.
-
“Seen a lot of DIY jobs come my way for fixes that cost more in the end.”
- My costs: $400/window for materials, but I forgot about dump fees and unexpected rot repair—added $150.
- Saved money, but honestly, lost a few weekends and had to borrow tools.
- Would maybe go pro next time just for the peace of mind...
That’s pretty much how my first window swap went—felt like I was saving until I hit the “unexpected rot repair” stage.
For me, the kicker was air sealing. Did you notice any drafts after? I found even tiny gaps made a difference in winter, and I ended up spending more on insulation foam and caulk than I thought. Curious if anyone’s tracked their energy bills after a DIY install vs pro?“forgot about dump fees and unexpected rot repair—added $150.”
For me, the kicker was air sealing. Did you notice any drafts after?
That’s the part a lot of folks underestimate—air sealing is sneaky important. Even a tiny missed spot can make the new window feel draftier than the old one. I’ve seen people save a few hundred on DIY, then lose it over two winters in higher bills. My own house, I went back twice with more caulk after realizing my “good enough” wasn’t quite cutting it. Energy bill barely budged until I got those last little gaps. Definitely not as plug-and-play as YouTube makes it look.
Even a tiny missed spot can make the new window feel draftier than the old one.
You nailed it—air sealing is where the real battle is. I thought I was being thorough, but after the first cold snap, I could literally feel a breeze by my living room window. Had to break out the smoke pen and hunt down every tiny gap. It’s kind of wild how much difference those little spots make. You’re not alone—getting it right takes patience, but it’s worth it when you finally see that energy bill drop.
That’s exactly the tricky part—folks focus so much on the window itself, but it’s really the air sealing that makes or breaks your comfort (and those bills). Did you check around the frame and sill too? Sometimes even a good caulk job misses spots if the wall isn’t square or there’s old debris. I’m curious—did you use low-expansion foam or stick with caulk? I’ve seen both work, but in older homes, gaps can be bigger than you think. It’s wild how a $5 tube of sealant can matter more than a $500 window sometimes.