"Ended up tearing them out and going for fiberglass frames with low-E glass."
Did you notice a big difference in noise reduction too? I've been debating fiberglass vs. higher-end vinyl myself... wondering if the extra cost really pays off beyond just energy savings.
I get the appeal of fiberglass, but honestly, from my experience, higher-end vinyl can be surprisingly effective for noise reduction too. I replaced some bedroom windows last year with premium vinyl frames and noticed a huge improvement in blocking street noise. Maybe fiberglass does have an edge in durability or aesthetics, but if noise is your main concern, vinyl might still do the trick without stretching your budget too far... Have you checked out any local showrooms to compare them in person?
Totally agree on vinyl being underrated. I went fiberglass for our living room windows thinking it'd be a huge upgrade, but honestly, the vinyl ones we put in the kids' rooms block noise just as well. My wallet still hasn't forgiven me for that one...
Interesting point about vinyl vs fiberglass. I've been eyeing fiberglass myself, thinking it's the quieter option...but now you've got me second-guessing. Did you notice any difference in insulation or durability, or was it pretty much a wash there too?
I've done both fiberglass and vinyl, and honestly, the insulation difference wasn't huge enough to sway me either way. Fiberglass felt a bit sturdier overall—especially during storms—but vinyl held up surprisingly well too. Noise-wise, I couldn't tell much of a difference. If you're budgeting, vinyl might leave some extra cash for better glass upgrades or weatherproofing...which could actually make more impact than frame material alone. Just my two cents!
I went vinyl about five years ago and honestly haven't regretted it. Like you said, the insulation difference wasn't huge enough to justify the extra cost of fiberglass for me. I took the savings and put it toward upgrading to double-pane low-E glass, and that made a noticeable difference in comfort and energy bills.
One thing I'd add though—installation quality matters a ton. My neighbor went fiberglass but skimped on installation, and he's had drafts and leaks ever since. Meanwhile, my vinyl windows have been rock solid through some pretty nasty storms. So whichever way you go, don't underestimate the importance of a good installer.
Also, if you're budgeting, keep an eye out for seasonal deals or rebates from your utility company. I lucked into a rebate program that saved me a couple hundred bucks...definitely worth checking into before you pull the trigger.
"installation quality matters a ton. My neighbor went fiberglass but skimped on installation, and he's had drafts and leaks ever since."
Couldn't agree more about installation quality. A few years back, I worked on a project where the homeowner opted for high-end fiberglass windows but chose an installer based purely on price. Unfortunately, the installer didn't properly seal or flash around the frames, and within months they were dealing with moisture intrusion and drafts—exactly what you're describing.
On the flip side, I've seen plenty of vinyl installations that have held up beautifully over time because the installers took their time to get it right. Proper flashing, sealing, and insulation around the window openings can make even mid-range vinyl windows perform exceptionally well.
Also, great tip about checking utility rebates. I've had clients save hundreds by timing their purchases around rebate programs or seasonal promotions. It's definitely worth doing a bit of homework upfront...those savings can really add up when you're budgeting for home improvements.