Windows discussions and local services.
Discussion options
Simonton, Jeld-Wen, or American Craftsman - best bang for the buck?
Been looking into windows lately since mine are getting pretty drafty. Narrowed it down to Simonton, Jeld-Wen, and American Craftsman. Anyone have experience with these brands? Curious which you'd recommend and why...
Join the conversation
Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.
2 replies
Went through this exact decision last year - ended up with Simonton. Here's why:
- Felt sturdier and better insulated compared to American Craftsman when I checked samples in-store.
- Jeld-Wen looked decent, but heard mixed reviews about their customer service if something goes wrong.
- Installation was smooth, and I've noticed a real difference in drafts (way less chilly now).
Overall, pretty satisfied with Simonton so far...but honestly, proper installation probably matters just as much as the brand.
The brand names alone don’t tell you which is the better deal. Compare quotes for the exact window series and whether each is for an insert or full-frame replacement. Those aren’t necessarily equivalent jobs: the scope and how much of the existing frame gets addressed can differ, affecting both price and what you’re getting for it. For anyone comparing these brands, do you know which series and replacement method are in each quote?