Stuck choosing between Kolbe and Andersen for my 90s home

82 replies 3,234 views
 
dlopez44
17 posts

Those corners are the bane of my existence - I swear, there’s always some mystery crud hiding in there from the previous owners. I did Andersen a few years back in my kitchen, and while they weren’t as hefty as Kolbe, they’ve held up surprisingly well. The price difference helped since I was juggling a bathroom reno at the same time. Have you noticed any real difference in drafts or noise between the two brands? That’s been my big concern with our old windows.


Reply
15 posts

- Dealt with both brands in my last house - Kolbe in the living room, Andersen in the back bedrooms.
- Honestly, Kolbe did seem a bit sturdier, but for drafts? Didn’t notice a huge difference. Maybe a tiny bit quieter with Kolbe, but nothing earth-shattering.
- Andersen’s easier on the wallet, and cleaning them didn’t make me want to rip my hair out.
- Still found dust bunnies in the corners no matter what, though... guess that’s just life with windows.


Reply
11 posts

Funny, I had the same Kolbe vs Andersen debate when I swapped out my 90s sliders. I geeked out over insulation ratings, but honestly, my cat cared more about the window sills than the actual windows. Kolbe felt a bit more “solid,” but my energy bill didn’t really notice. If you’re into gadgets, Kolbe’s hardware is a little more satisfying, but Andersen’s tilt-in cleaning is way less of a pain. Either way, dust bunnies are eternal.


Reply

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.