I hear you on the foam headaches. I used to be a foam-everywhere guy, but after chasing down some mystery drafts in a 1970s split-level last winter, I started rethinking things. The tape method took more time upfront, but it actually held up better through freeze-thaw cycles—no weird gaps or crunchy bits popping loose. Still use foam for those big, ugly voids, but for tight corners and seams, tape’s just cleaner. Funny how much those little tweaks matter when you’re the one getting the call-backs...
Funny how much those little tweaks matter when you’re the one getting the call-backs...
Ain’t that the truth. I used to be all-in on foam too, mostly because it’s quick and you feel like you’re really sealing stuff up. But after a couple jobs where the foam shrank and I ended up with “foam fossils” falling out of the trim, I started mixing it up. Tape’s not as satisfying to squish in there, but it’s way less drama later.
Here’s my usual play-by-play: big gaps get the low-expansion foam (not the stuff that turns into a marshmallow monster), then I hit the seams with high-quality tape. The trick is making sure everything’s dry and dust-free—learned that the hard way after a tape job peeled off in one go like a cartoon banana. Also, don’t cheap out on the tape. The bargain rolls are basically fancy stickers.
Honestly, those little details—like running a bead of caulk over the tape in the corners—have saved me a bunch of headaches. Not glamorous work, but it beats getting called back in January when your nose hairs freeze.
The bargain rolls are basically fancy stickers.
Gotta admit, I’m still a foam loyalist for the most part. Maybe I’m just stubborn, but I’ve had better luck with it in my drafty old place than tape. Tape always seems to peel for me, even when I go all-in with the expensive stuff. Maybe it’s my 100-year-old window frames or just bad tape karma, who knows. I do back it up with a bead of caulk though, so maybe that’s why I haven’t had the “foam fossils” problem… yet.
Tape always seems to peel for me, even when I go all-in with the expensive stuff.
That’s a common complaint, especially on older wood frames. I’ve seen tape let go after a couple seasons, even when folks prepped the surface. Foam’s definitely more forgiving with uneven sills and those little gaps you get in century-old houses. Curious—have you ever tried one of the hybrid sealants, like the flexible caulk that stays rubbery? I’ve had better luck with that in tricky spots than either tape or foam alone. Wondering if it’d hold up better in your place.
Foam’s definitely more forgiving with uneven sills and those little gaps you get in century-old houses.
Totally agree—foam’s been my go-to for the weird angles in my 1920s place. Tape just never seems to want to stick, especially in the winter when everything shrinks and shifts. I actually tried one of those “forever flexible” caulks last fall and, knock on wood, it’s holding up better than anything else so far. Little messy to work with, but I’ll take that over re-taping every year. If you go that route, just mask off the area first—ask me how I know...
foam’s been my go-to for the weird angles in my 1920s place. Tape just never seems to want to stick, especially in the winter when everything shrinks and shifts.
That shrinking and shifting is the bane of my existence every January... I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve had to redo tape jobs because a draft found its way in. Foam’s a lifesaver, especially for those spots where nothing is quite square. The only thing I’d add—watch out for overfilling with expanding foam. First time I did it, I thought “more is better,” and ended up having to trim blobs of it off the trim after it dried. Not my proudest moment.
I’m with you on the flexible caulk too—it’s messy, but once you get the hang of taping (and learn to keep a roll of blue tape handy), it beats scraping off old, cracked stuff every spring. If I could go back, I’d just spend the extra time masking instead of trying to be a hero freehanding it.
Only other detail that made a real difference for me was making sure the bottom sill gets sealed well. Missed that once and found out after a rainstorm... lesson learned.
First time I did it, I thought “more is better,” and ended up having to trim blobs of it off the trim after it dried.
Been there—foam expands like it’s auditioning for a sci-fi movie. One thing I learned the hard way: don’t forget to check for hidden gaps behind the casing. Thought I nailed it, then felt a breeze next winter. Turns out, old houses are full of surprises...
Totally get what you mean about old houses.
I thought I’d sealed everything too, but found a hidden gap behind some trim months later. Did you notice a real difference after you found those gaps? Sometimes I wonder if it’s all worth the hassle or if there’s always going to be a draft somewhere.“Turns out, old houses are full of surprises...”
I hear you about the endless surprises—old houses are like that, always hiding something behind the next molding. I did notice a difference after tracking down a couple of those sneaky gaps, but honestly, I still get a faint draft when the wind’s just right. It’s like chasing your own tail sometimes. Did you end up pulling off a lot of trim, or just spot-checking? I’m still debating whether it’s worth tearing into more or just accepting a little “historic ventilation.”
Totally get what you mean about chasing drafts—sometimes it feels like the house is just determined to keep a little breeze going, no matter what you do. I went through this last winter and ended up pulling off more trim than I planned... honestly, some of the gaps I found were wild. But after sealing those up with some low-expanding foam, it really cut down on the cold spots, at least in the main rooms.
That said, there's still a faint draft in one corner when the wind really kicks up, so I’m not sure you ever get it 100% tight in these old places. Did you notice any difference in specific rooms or was it pretty much the same around the whole house? Sometimes I wonder if it's worth the effort for every single spot or if it's smarter to just focus on the worst offenders and call it good. Curious if anyone’s tried those fancy draft stoppers or just stuck with caulk and weatherstripping like me.