Funny, I thought new windows would be the magic bullet too. When I swapped out my old single panes for double-panes, I was expecting a big drop in street noise. It helped some, but honestly, the biggest difference came after I found all the sneaky gaps around the frames and sill. Ended up crawling around with a caulk gun and some foam—definitely not glamorous, like you said, but wow, it made a bigger dent than the window swap alone. These old houses really do keep you on your toes.
You're spot on with this. I see a lot of folks expecting new windows to be the end-all solution, but it’s rarely that simple—especially in older homes.
-
“Ended up crawling around with a caulk gun and some foam—definitely not glamorous, like you said, but wow, it made a bigger dent than the window swap alone.”
- Air gaps are sneaky. Even the best double-pane won’t block noise if sound’s leaking through cracks and old trim.
- I’ve seen 1920s houses where the original frames had gaps big enough to feel a draft in winter... no wonder noise gets through.
- Window upgrades help, especially laminated glass or triple-pane, but sealing up those little leaks is huge. Sometimes, weatherstripping makes more difference than people think.
- Not glamorous work, but it’s usually cheaper and more effective per dollar than just swapping out glass.
You did it right by tackling both. Honestly, it’s always a combo of fixes—windows, insulation, sealing gaps—that really brings city noise down. Old houses keep us humble... and busy.
I get where you’re coming from, but I’ll be honest—when I swapped out my old single-pane windows for good triple-pane, it made a night-and-day difference. Yeah, I did the caulking and foam thing too (who hasn’t spent a Saturday with a caulk gun?), but in my place, the actual glass was the main culprit. The original windows rattled every time a truck went by, and no amount of weatherstripping really fixed that.
I think it depends a lot on the house and what you’re starting with. If your windows are ancient and leaky, sure, seal everything up first. But sometimes, the window itself is just too flimsy for city noise—especially if you’re near a main road. Laminated glass was a game changer for me, even more than the gap sealing. Not cheap, but honestly worth it for the peace and quiet.
Guess it’s one of those “your mileage may vary” deals. Some folks get away with just sealing, others need the full window overhaul. Old houses definitely keep us guessing...
Triple-pane, huh? That’s living the dream. I’ve always wondered if those would make enough of a difference to justify the price tag, especially for my cranky old place. I’m still rocking the original 1950s wood frames, so sometimes it feels like there’s just a thin sheet of plastic wrap between me and the garbage trucks at 6 a.m. I did the whole caulking/weatherstripping extravaganza last winter—felt like I was playing Whac-A-Mole with drafts—but you’re right, at some point the glass itself is just too wimpy for city noise.
I tried those stick-on window film kits once (you know, the ones where you blast them with a hair dryer and they’re supposed to seal everything up). They helped a little with drafts, but for sound? Not so much. Still got serenaded by every car alarm on the block.
Laminated glass is tempting, though. My buddy did that in his rowhouse and swears his blood pressure dropped overnight. I’m just dragging my feet because, yeah, not exactly pocket change. Plus, I’m stubborn and keep thinking maybe THIS year I’ll finally get the gaps sealed just right... but I think you nailed it—it depends on how bad things are to start with. Some houses are just destined to be noisy unless you go all-in.
One thing I’ll say: if you’re even half-handy, replacing the weatherstripping and adding foam tape is a cheap experiment before you shell out for new windows. But if your windows rattle in the wind like mine, might be time to start saving up for the real deal. Old houses really do love to keep us on our toes... or maybe just slightly sleep-deprived.