Yeah, the dust thing caught me off guard too—my allergies are thanking me, honestly. I did new windows last fall and got a little something back from the state, but nothing huge. Install was a mess here too, especially in the kitchen where nothing’s square (old house probs). Haven’t seen my bills drop much yet, but at least I can sit by the window without freezing my butt off.
Totally get the old house headache—nothing lines up, and every “quick” job turns into a whole thing. I had the same issue with my 1920s place. Installers ended up shaving down parts of the trim just to make the windows sit right. Not the prettiest, but at least there’s no draft now.
Honestly, I expected more of a drop in my heating bill too, but it’s been pretty minor. Wonder if it’s just the age of the house or maybe insulation elsewhere isn’t up to snuff. Still, not having to pile on blankets just to read by the window is a win in my book.
Did you notice any noise difference after the new windows went in? Mine cut down street noise a bit, which was a nice bonus I hadn’t even considered.
Installers ended up shaving down parts of the trim just to make the windows sit right. Not the prettiest, but at least there’s no draft now.
That’s exactly what happened in my place—nothing is square, so every window felt like a custom job. I actually tried to measure everything myself before the installers showed up, thinking I’d save time, but it turned out every frame was a little off. Ended up with a few gaps that needed extra foam and some creative caulking.
As for the bills, I was expecting a bigger difference too. Maybe I set my expectations too high, but it’s only been a slight drop. I’m wondering if it’s the attic insulation or maybe the basement that’s letting all the heat out. Step-by-step, I’m trying to tackle one drafty spot at a time... just not sure where the biggest leak is.
Noise-wise, though, I did notice a change. Used to hear traffic all the time, especially in the mornings. Now it’s just kind of a low hum, which is a relief. Makes me think maybe I should look into soundproofing some of the interior doors next.
I actually tried to measure everything myself before the installers showed up, thinking I’d save time, but it turned out every frame was a little off.
Right there with you. My house must’ve settled in three different directions over the years—nothing lines up. The installers had to do some “creative carpentry” around here too. I also thought my bills would nosedive, but nope, just a modest dip so far. On the bright side, the dog doesn’t bark at every passing truck now... Small wins, I guess. I keep eyeing the attic insulation too, but honestly, after wrestling with those windows, might need a break before the next project.
- Honestly, I got a bigger drop in my bills than I expected—maybe 18% over last winter.
-
I also thought my bills would nosedive, but nope, just a modest dip so far.
- Did you check for air leaks around the frames after install? Sometimes even new windows need extra sealing, especially in older homes.
- Attic insulation made a bigger difference for me than the windows did. Not fun to install, but worth it.
I’m not convinced new windows are the magic bullet everyone claims. I swapped mine out two winters ago—nice upgrade, but honestly, my heating bill barely budged. Air sealing and attic insulation gave me way more bang for my buck. Windows look great, sure, but the payoff’s slower than most folks expect.
Yeah, I’m right there with you. We did the whole window replacement thing about three years ago—everyone kept saying it would make a huge difference, but honestly, my bills barely changed. The house does feel less drafty and the noise from outside isn’t as bad, so I guess there’s that. But in terms of actual savings? Not much to write home about.
What really moved the needle for us was getting all those little air leaks sealed up. Found a bunch around the basement rim joists and where pipes go through the walls—stuff I never even thought about before. Spent a weekend with a few cans of spray foam and some weatherstripping, and saw more improvement than after dropping thousands on new windows.
Insulation in the attic made a noticeable difference too. Our place is old (built in the 60s) and whoever insulated it originally must’ve been half asleep because there were bare spots everywhere. Rolled out some new batts myself and suddenly the upstairs wasn’t freezing all winter.
Not saying new windows are useless—they look nice, open easier, and don’t rattle when it’s windy—but if you’re expecting a big drop in your utility bill right away, it’s probably not happening. Seems like they’re more of a long-term thing or for comfort/looks than an instant money saver.
Funny how everyone pushes windows as the first upgrade when there’s so much low-hanging fruit elsewhere... Maybe it just sounds fancier than “seal your attic hatch.”
Yeah, that’s been my experience too—windows look nice and all, but the real savings came from chasing down drafts and beefing up insulation. I always wonder if the window hype is just good marketing or what. Did you ever try one of those home energy audits? We had one done and the guy basically ignored the windows and pointed out a bunch of random leaks I never would’ve found. Curious if those audits actually helped anyone else find “hidden” problems.
We had one done and the guy basically ignored the windows and pointed out a bunch of random leaks I never would’ve found.
That matches my experience almost exactly. I used to think new windows were the holy grail for energy savings, but after living through a couple of brutal winters, it turned out the attic insulation and sealing up weird little gaps around the basement made a much bigger difference. The audit was eye-opening—he found air leaking in behind an old electrical outlet and through the attic hatch. Windows look nice, sure, but I’m convinced the real savings are in the stuff you can’t see. Marketing definitely plays a part in the window hype, at least in my opinion.
I get where you’re coming from—attic insulation and sealing up weird nooks really does make a noticeable difference. But I’ll be honest, I had the opposite experience with our windows. Our house is from the 60s, and the old single-pane windows were so drafty that you could actually feel cold air blowing in on windy days. We’d stuffed towels along the sills and tried all those shrink-wrap kits, but it barely helped.
When we finally bit the bullet and replaced them (painful price tag, not gonna lie), the difference was immediate. The rooms closest to the old windows used to be freezing in winter and boiling in summer, but after the swap, temps evened out a ton. Our heating bill dropped about 20% that first winter. Maybe it’s because our old windows were just that bad? Or maybe newer builds don’t see as much benefit, I dunno.
I do agree that marketing probably oversells how much new windows will save everyone—it’s not magic. But if your windows are ancient or super leaky, they can still be a major culprit. I guess it depends on how bad your originals are. For us, attic insulation helped too, but nothing matched changing out those rattly old panes.
Kind of funny how every house has its own quirks when it comes to energy leaks... what works for one place might not move the needle in another.