Which is more annoying: smart window disconnects or battery problems?

Honestly, I’m right there with you on the battery thing. Swapping out AAs at 2am because some window sensor decided to start chirping is the worst. At least with signal drops, I can usually fix it by moving my hub or adding a cheap repeater. Batteries just feel like a never-ending chore... and somehow they *always* die in winter when it’s freezing and I least want to mess with them.

I get where you’re coming from, but honestly, the disconnects drive me up the wall more than batteries. At least when a sensor battery goes, I know what’s wrong and can fix it with a quick swap (even if it means braving the cold in my slippers). But when my window sensors randomly drop off the network, I end up spending ages troubleshooting. Last month one sensor vanished for two days—turned out to be interference from my neighbor’s new WiFi router. Batteries are annoying, but at least they don’t play hide and seek...

I get what you're saying about disconnects being a nightmare, but honestly, I’d take a random drop-off over crawling around looking for those tiny coin batteries any day. Maybe it’s just my luck, but I swear my sensors only die when I’m already halfway out the door or, worse, in the middle of a snowstorm. Had one in the guest room window go out last winter—of course, I didn’t have a spare battery, so I had to “borrow” one from my kid’s toy robot. Cue the meltdown.

Network hiccups are frustrating, no doubt, but at least I can usually fix those with a router reboot or moving the sensor an inch to the left. Batteries, though, have this knack for dying at the least convenient moment. Plus, half the time I forget which drawer the spares are in... Maybe it comes down to which kind of chaos you prefer—tech gremlins or battery scavenger hunts.

I totally get the battery struggle—those coin cells always seem to vanish when you need them most. I started keeping a little organizer box in the kitchen drawer just for spare batteries, but even then, I forget to restock after a swap. For what it’s worth, I switched a couple sensors to rechargeable AA models (with adapters) and it’s been a game changer. Still, I’ll take a network dropout over a dead sensor in January... at least I don’t have to raid my kid’s toys or go digging behind furniture.

I’ll admit, I’m not totally sold on rechargeable AAs for every sensor—some of those adapters can be finicky, and I’ve seen them lose contact in cold weather. Still, it beats hunting for coin cells at 10pm. Network dropouts drive me nuts, though. At least with batteries, you can swap them and move on... but when the smart window goes offline, you’re stuck troubleshooting Wi-Fi or zigbee for an hour. In older houses like mine, thick walls don’t help. Both are a hassle, just depends which one crops up first.

I hear you on the thick walls—my 1920s place is basically a Wi-Fi dead zone in half the rooms. I’ve had sensors drop offline for days just because the signal can’t make it through the plaster. Swapping batteries is annoying, but at least it’s predictable. Ever tried one of those mesh repeaters or just stuck with moving hubs around? I’m still not sure what’s less of a pain: running extension cords for better coverage or keeping a drawer full of batteries.

Swapping batteries is annoying, but at least it’s predictable.

Honestly, I’d take battery swaps over random disconnects any day. At least you know when you’re due for a change, and you can keep a stash handy. I tried mesh repeaters last year (Netgear Orbi), and they did help, but those thick walls still eat up signal in the weirdest spots. Running cords everywhere just feels like giving up, but sometimes it’s the only option if you want everything to work without constant headaches.

Yeah, I’m with you—random disconnects drive me nuts. At least with batteries, it’s like, “Okay, time to swap.” But those dropouts? Never seem to happen when I’m just tinkering around—always when I’m out or trying to show off the setup. I’ve got an old brick house, so signal’s just a pain sometimes. Honestly, running cords is ugly but at least it works... most of the time.

Funny how it’s always the signal that flakes when you’re showing off, right? I’ll take ugly cords over mystery disconnects any day. At least with a cord, you know what’s going on. Wireless is great until it isn’t... especially in these older houses with thick walls.

- Totally get the “ugly cords over mystery disconnects” vibe.
-

Wireless is great until it isn’t... especially in these older houses with thick walls.