Noise difference? Oh yeah, big time. I swapped out a set of ancient double-hungs for a couple in an old brick house last fall—think windows so loose you could almost hear the neighbor sneeze. After the new Simontons went in, they joked it was like living in a library. The street noise, barking dogs, even that weird wind whistling sound just… stopped. I mean, you’ll still hear the garbage truck if you’re right by the window, but it’s way less harsh.
I get missing the wavy glass though. There’s something about that old-school vibe—like the house has stories to tell. Honestly, one lady asked me to save a few panes so she could make picture frames. Not a bad idea if you’re sentimental about it.
Upfront cost is definitely a gut punch, not gonna sugarcoat it. But between the energy savings and the financing deals (that 0% thing from Simonton isn’t too shabby if you qualify), it takes some of the sting out. Plus, if you’re like me and hate wrestling with plastic film every winter, it’s a relief.
One thing I always warn folks about: modern windows are tighter, which is great for drafts and bills, but sometimes you’ll notice your house feels “stiller.” If you’re used to a little airflow, it takes getting used to. And if you have an older house, check if you need extra vents or anything—sometimes those places relied on leaky windows for fresh air, believe it or not.
Curious what everyone else thinks about the noise thing. I’ve heard mixed reviews depending on the style and install job.