We're finally replacing our old drafty windows (yay, adulting) and narrowed it down to Simonton and either Pella or Andersen's vinyl lines. Simonton seems more budget-friendly, but I've heard mixed things about durability. Andersen and Pella have solid reps, but are they really worth the extra cash? Anyone here have experience with either brand long-term? Curious if the pricier options actually hold up better over time or if it's mostly marketing hype.
We went with Andersen vinyl windows about 7 years ago, and honestly, zero regrets. My brother-in-law chose Simonton around the same time to save a bit, and he's already had to replace seals on a couple windows. Sometimes paying a little extra upfront saves headaches later...
We recently replaced the original windows in our house with Andersen vinyl windows, and I can see why you're happy with them. I spent way too much time comparing specs—U-factor, SHGC ratings, warranty details, you name it—and Andersen consistently came out ahead. Yeah, they're pricier upfront, but after reading countless reviews about seal failures and fogging issues with cheaper brands, it seemed worth it. So far, no issues here either... fingers crossed it stays that way.