Notifications
Clear all

can you really trust those instant online window estimates?

7 Posts
7 Users
0 Reactions
53 Views
katieknitter
Posts: 2
Topic starter
(@katieknitter)
New Member
Joined:

Been thinking about replacing the windows in my place, and I keep seeing these sites that promise instant quotes if you just punch in your measurements and stuff. But, um, what if you measure wrong or the site doesn't factor in something important like weird framing or old house quirks? Seems convenient, sure, but I'm kinda skeptical. Anyone here ever actually relied on one of these quick online estimates and had it turn out accurate?

6 Replies
Posts: 9
(@william_young)
Active Member
Joined:

I've seen those instant quote things work out pretty well, actually...but mostly for straightforward jobs. If your place has quirks or older framing, I'd still recommend getting someone out there to eyeball it. Saves headaches later, trust me.

Reply
environment_jon
Posts: 11
(@environment_jon)
Active Member
Joined:

I've had decent luck with those instant quotes too, especially for standard-sized windows. But when we renovated our older home, the online estimate was way off because of some hidden framing issues we didn't even know existed until the installer came out. Ended up costing more than expected, but at least we caught it early. Curious though, has anyone here actually had an instant quote match perfectly with their final bill on an older property?

Reply
Posts: 11
(@swoof99)
Active Member
Joined:

Instant quotes can be handy for ballpark figures, but honestly, I've rarely seen them spot-on for older homes. Too many hidden quirks pop up—rotted sills, weird framing, you name it. Always better to budget a bit extra just in case...

Reply
Posts: 9
(@fitness113)
Active Member
Joined:

Totally agree with budgeting extra—learned that lesson the hard way myself. When we replaced windows in our 1920s bungalow, the instant quote looked great at first, but once the installers got started, they found some rotted framing and uneven openings. Ended up costing us about 20% more than expected. I'd say use those online estimates as a starting point, then add a cushion for surprises. Older homes always have a few secrets hiding behind the walls...

Reply
Posts: 8
(@frodoe79)
Active Member
Joined:

Yeah, those online estimates are handy for ballpark numbers, but honestly, they're more like the "wishful thinking" version of your final bill. I've done a bunch of window replacements in older houses, and trust me, the surprises never end. One time we pulled out a window and found newspapers from the 1930s stuffed in as insulation—interesting history lesson, terrible insulation method.

Usually, I'll tell clients to mentally tack on at least 15-25% to any online quote. And if you're dealing with anything built before WWII, maybe even more. Those old homes have character for days, but that character usually comes with hidden rot, wonky framing, or DIY fixes from someone who probably shouldn't have been allowed near a hammer.

So yeah, use those instant estimates as a rough starting point—but keep some extra funds handy for when your walls decide to share their secrets...

Reply
Posts: 6
(@maggiesage270)
Active Member
Joined:

Gotta say, I've had a slightly different experience. Did a window replacement on my 1920s bungalow last year, and the online estimate was surprisingly close—only off by about 5%. Maybe I just got lucky, or maybe it depends on how detailed you get with the info you plug in. But yeah, old houses definitely have their quirks...mine had some sketchy wiring hiding behind the trim. Fun times.

Reply
Share:
Scroll to Top