How tricky is it to make a window bigger?

Tried this a couple years back when we wanted more sunlight in our kitchen. Honestly, it’s not as simple as just knocking out some drywall and popping in a bigger window. Once you start messing with the framing, you’re into structural territory—headers, supports, all that jazz. My buddy and I are pretty handy, but we still brought in a contractor for the rough opening because I didn’t want to risk messing up the load-bearing wall. It was pricier than I hoped, but I slept easier. Not saying it’s impossible for a DIYer, but there’s more to it than YouTube makes it look.

- Totally agree—expanding a window isn’t just a “cut and go” project.
- Framing changes mean you’re messing with the structure, especially if it’s a load-bearing wall.
- You’ll probably need a bigger header to distribute weight. That’s not something I’d want to guess on.
- I’ve done smaller window swaps solo, but sizing up? I’d at least consult a pro or an engineer.
- Also, don’t forget permits—my city’s strict about that stuff.
- Not impossible, but definitely more work (and risk) than most DIY videos show.

- You’re spot on about the structural stuff.
-

“Not impossible, but definitely more work (and risk) than most DIY videos show.”

Couldn’t agree more—YouTube makes it look easy, but there’s a lot they skip.
- If you do go for it, take the chance to upgrade to a high-efficiency window. Made a noticeable difference in my heating bill after I did mine.
- Just double check your city’s permit rules... mine was stricter than I expected.

That’s a solid reminder about the permit situation—my city was picky too, even wanted engineer-stamped drawings for anything messing with headers. I did this a couple years back and went with triple-pane for the new opening. The difference in drafts and noise was huge, but honestly, the mess and dust lingered for weeks. If you’re already opening up the wall, it really is the perfect time to step up your window’s efficiency, though it’s not cheap. Just be ready for a bit more chaos than most tutorials show.

Yeah, the dust is no joke—demoing a wall for a bigger window always creates more mess than folks expect. I’ve seen people underestimate the header work too; city inspectors around here are sticklers for that. Triple-pane is definitely a nice upgrade if your budget can swing it, especially for noise. Just be ready for some surprises once you open up the wall—sometimes you find old wiring or weird framing that needs fixing.

I get the appeal of triple-pane, but honestly, I’ve seen folks in milder climates regret the extra spend. Unless you’re right on a noisy street or dealing with brutal winters, good double-pane with proper sealing does the trick for most. The real headaches usually come from those “surprises” in the wall—last year I opened up a 1920s place and found brick stuffed in for insulation. That slowed us down way more than any inspector ever did. Sometimes it’s not the window, it’s what’s hiding behind it...

- Making a window bigger isn’t just about cutting drywall—there’s a lot more going on behind the scenes.
-

Sometimes it’s not the window, it’s what’s hiding behind it...

Couldn’t agree more. When we opened up our living room wall, we found some old knob-and-tube wiring right where the new header needed to go. That was a whole detour.
- Structurally, you’ll need to reroute framing—usually means adding a bigger header to carry the load above. Not always DIY-friendly.
- If your house is older, expect surprises: weird insulation (or none at all), hidden pipes, maybe even critter nests.
- For us, labor costs jumped once the contractor saw what was inside. Budget for that just in case.

Is it always necessary to bump up the header size, though? I get the structural concern, but in my 1950s ranch, the span wasn’t huge and our inspector said the existing framing could handle a slightly wider window. Maybe it depends on wall load and window placement? Sometimes contractors default to overbuilding just to be safe, but I wonder if that always adds real value—or just cost.

I hear you on the overbuilding thing—sometimes it feels like contractors want to put a steel beam in for a bathroom window “just in case.” When we swapped out our tiny kitchen window for something that actually let in sunlight, our guy took one look at the original header and said, “Eh, this’ll do.” Inspector agreed, too. I think with these older houses, especially ranches, there’s often more wood than necessary anyway.

You’re right though—it really depends on what’s above. If you’re under an attic or just roof load, sometimes the existing framing can handle a little more width without drama. But if there’s a second story or some weird load path, that’s when things get dicey.

Honestly, I’d rather not pay for extra lumber unless it’s actually needed. But I get why contractors play it safe—nobody wants callbacks about sagging drywall. Still, if your inspector gave it the thumbs up and you’re not opening up a whole wall, seems like you’re good to go.